Jump to content

dgage

Members
  • Content Count

    290
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    33

dgage last won the day on September 24

dgage had the most liked content!

Community Reputation

106 Excellent

About dgage

  • Rank
    Ultra Member

Recent Profile Visitors

663 profile views
  1. And it expired today so someone can take off with it if they so desired.
  2. Maybe your film composer buddy could ask some of the audio engineers that finalize the soundtrack to speak to some of the things we find when reviewing movie soundtracks, especially some of the filtering that appears to get applied. I’d be interested if they could speak to what is being done (software, plugin?) and why. And then a way to reach out to that community so we can nicely ask them to stop putting out neutered soundtracks. One could wish.
  3. But why neuter the sound below 25 Hz unnecessarily? If a system can’t play that low, it’s just like systems that can’t play to 20,000 Hz, no big deal. But once they start putting these canned filters in the bass, they’re negatively affecting the soundtrack for no good reason. I wonder how many would cry if they started rolling off the top end at 18,000 Hz. Oh well, I was about to write, I wish I knew how to get through to these soundtrack engineers and then I thought about them having a trade group or society. Does anyone know what group the soundtrack engineers might be members of?
  4. Well movies are much more subjective and creative from the initial story to how it is converted to a movie. Then there’s the direction and cutting of the film and many, many other pieces. So I can understand when that isn’t so good. But come on, for a blockbuster, there really isn’t an excuse for these amateur heavy handed shortcut filters that boost and filter audio for no good reason. Sound is much less subjective and could be more scientific or at least prescriptive. At the very least for a given studio, it should be consistent but we don’t even see that. Movie audio today is the wild west with little quality and absolutely no consistency. McDonalds may not be good but they’re popular due to their consistency (and marketing). Anyway, I could argue for hours due to how frustrated this makes me when hearing different movie soundtracks. I’m done venting.
  5. Maybe they just assign the home movie soundtracks to the interns. I mean, it’s only for the home, people will just listen on TV speakers anyway. Of course that doesn’t explain why some of the theater soundtracks are also so bad.
  6. You keep quoting me but I don’t think I ever wrote those. But really nice work.
  7. My thoughts on the practice? I think the sound engineers should act like professional engineers and do a professional job. It seems like they have 100 soundtracks a year to do and can’t be bothered to do it right. It’s maddening that a Blu-ray would be released to millions of customers with such shoddy work. They should be ashamed but for all I know, they have little control. Whatever the issues, it is a pretty poor practice for something involving millions of dollars.
  8. You may not be able to hear the SQL-15 in a theater room but you can hear it in Nick’s car. Reach out to him, his email (sales@) is on his website and ask him if you can come hear it, he is a very gracious host though his email habits aren’t the best. If you don’t get an email response within a few days, PM me and I’ll ping him. He also has the HST-11s in his home theater in a dual-opposed square tube but that tube is probably too heavy to move just due to the 70lb magnet motors on the HST series. And yes, I wasn’t sure I wanted to respond to someone who might ONLY want 12” subs. Lol! Glad you’re here and glad we provided some useful info. Great and incredibly knowledgeable people on this forum.
  9. And I just talked to Nick of Stereo Integrity and he’ll be coming out with a more sensitive and less expensive set of 12 and 15” subs near the end of the year, which might be worth checking out. They’ll also dig pretty deep in a fairly small enclosure, 2 cuft for 15”. However I wouldn’t consider those if you’re wanting to move forward in the next month or two.
  10. I use Stereo Integrity subs for my commercial subs so I’m partial to those and know they perform well. The HST-18 is a really powerful driver that is one of the most powerful you can get. SI also makes smaller diameter subs using the same magnet-motor in the HST-11, 12, 15, etc thought they may be more expensive than many other drivers. But I heard the HST-11 and a pair of those were impressive in very small enclosures so while the value may not be there, you have a lot more flexibility with placement. ‘And I’m not a big fan of dual-opposed simply because their advantage, vibration canceling, isn’t that big a difference with a well-built large single sub. And the disadvantage of placement options is what I really dislike as their best placement is midwall running parallel to the wall and not many have that position available. ‘’And if you’re thinking a coffee table, I’d personally go for a well-built down-firing coffee table. Or a pair of end tables or similar, which you can spread out a little better. Also think about size vs location in respect to your main listening position. Maybe place a larger sub near the front of the room and a smaller driver near your primary seat. The SI HST series could help with this as the sonic signature is the same while the output is slightly different, stronger up front with a larger driver, and less output near your seat since you don’t need the closer sub to play as loud to keep up with the front.
  11. It’s actually 2 12” (amplifying both subs) almost equal a 15” and 2 15” almost equal a powerful 18”. 2 18” almost equal a 24” sub. Generalization but fairly accurate. And I always recommend at least two smaller subs than 1 larger sub though I wouldn’t go less than 15” in size. The reason for multiple subs is to even out the bass in the room, dismissing improvement above 4. If you play a single sub in a room, walk around it and you’ll hear boomy bass in some areas such as the corners and in other areas the bass will be weaker. So for best bass consider 2 of whatever subs you can fit.
  12. Wow! Great job! Fantastic attention to detail. Can’t wait to see the final result.
  13. Looks great. How smooth did it turn out on the inside?
  14. You’d think professional engineers with their name on something that will heard by tens of millions would take a little more pride. I’m surprised by how many movie sound tracks have such poor audio. I guess they tune for a sound bar and move on to the next poor movie soundtrack. I feel my blood pressure boiling. 👹
×
×
  • Create New...